Do positive affirmations work? A psychologist unpacks the evidence

Do Positive Affirmations Work? A Psychologist Unpacks the Evidence

Scroll through social media, and phrases like "I am worthy" or "I choose happiness" appear everywhere. The promise seems simple: repeat these positive affirmations consistently, and you’ll experience greater happiness, calmness, and even improved health. Given our biological drive to avoid suffering and seek safety and happiness, this approach is undeniably tempting. But does science support these claims? And are there potential drawbacks?

Understanding Positive Affirmations

The Foundation of Self-Affirmation Theory
Psychologist Claude Steele introduced self-affirmation theory in the late 1980s. This theory suggests humans possess a deep-rooted need to maintain a personal narrative where we see ourselves as "adequate" and "worthy." Painful experiences—like academic failure, workplace errors, or breakups—trigger shame or embarrassment, threatening this self-narrative. This can lead to heightened self-criticism, increasing vulnerability to anxiety, depression, or even self-harm. Positive affirmations aim to counteract this by reinforcing self-worth and protecting mental health.

Examining the Evidence: Do Positive Affirmations Work?

Research reveals a nuanced picture—positive affirmations can be effective, but their impact is often limited and context-dependent.

- Advertisement -

Key Findings:

• A 2025 review analyzing 67 studies found affirmations had a small but meaningful effect on self-perception and social connection.
• Specific groups saw benefits: Social media users experienced protection for self-esteem, university students reported better mental health, and breast cancer patients listening to affirmations during chemotherapy felt reduced depression and drowsiness.
• Adults with undiagnosed depression symptoms who wrote personal affirmations twice daily for 15 days showed improved self-esteem.

Important Caveats:

• A frequently cited 2009 study revealed a critical limitation: Affirmations like "I am a lovable person" only boosted mood in individuals with already high self-esteem. Those with low self-esteem reported worse mood.
• Recent studies have struggled to replicate earlier positive findings, indicating more research is needed to clarify who benefits and under what conditions.

The Hidden Risks: Downsides of Positive Affirmations

While appealing, forcing positivity carries significant psychological risks:

1. Toxic Positivity
Humans are imperfect, and life is often unfair. Suppressing genuine distress with affirmations leads to toxic positivity, where difficult feelings are denied. This creates pressure to "reframe" negativity at all costs. When individuals inevitably fail, they may feel shame and avoid seeking real help.

2. The Dopamine Trap
Repeating affirmations can trigger dopamine release, creating a fleeting sense of control and pleasure. However, chasing constant euphoria is unrealistic. Over time, this can evolve into a damaging cycle where individuals compulsively seek the next emotional "high" to avoid discomfort.

3. Downplaying Real Dangers
Positive self-talk is only helpful in genuinely safe contexts. In abusive relationships or toxic environments, affirmations like "I choose peace" can blind individuals to real threats, overriding crucial gut instincts. This detachment discourages necessary action, like leaving harmful situations.

What Actually Works? Alternatives to Positive Affirmations

Evidence suggests how we speak to ourselves matters more than forced optimism. Two effective alternatives:

Practice Self-Compassion
Research shows treating yourself with kindness during stress builds resilience. Phrases like "This is hard, and that’s okay" or "Anyone would struggle here" are more effective than generic positivity. Acknowledging suffering and responding as you would to a friend validates emotions without judgment.

Create Psychological Distance
Using third-person self-talk (e.g., "Alex is upset but has handled worse") creates space between you and distressing thoughts. This "non-attachment" approach helps regulate emotions by observing feelings with curiosity rather than reacting impulsively. Studies show it encourages adaptive coping strategies.

Conclusion: Balance Over Blind Positivity

No single mindset works universally. The key is psychological flexibility—asking "Is this thought helpful?" and adapting your approach. While affirmations may offer limited benefits in specific scenarios, they risk toxic positivity, emotional dependency, or dangerous detachment. Prioritize realistic self-compassion and non-attached observation over simplistic slogans. Your mental health benefits most from honesty, not forced cheerfulness.

FAQs About Positive Affirmations

1. Can positive affirmations actually change my brain?
While affirmations can trigger dopamine, there’s no strong evidence they rewire the brain long-term. Their effects are typically short-lived, especially without deeper behavioral or emotional work.

2. Are affirmations harmful for people with depression?
Potentially. Research shows forced positivity can worsen mood in individuals with low self-esteem or depression. Self-compassion techniques are generally safer and more effective for these groups.

3. How often should I practice affirmations if I use them?
There’s no universal rule, but quality matters more than quantity. Forcing repetitions when they feel inauthentic can backfire. Focus on situations where they feel genuinely resonant.

4. What’s the difference between toxic positivity and healthy optimism?
Healthy optimism acknowledges challenges while focusing on growth. Toxic positivity dismisses or invalidates genuine pain (e.g., "Just stay positive!" instead of "This is really hard—how can I support you?").

5. Can affirmations help with anxiety?
In controlled environments, affirmations might offer temporary calm by redirecting focus. However, techniques like mindfulness or cognitive distancing provide deeper, more sustainable relief for chronic anxiety.