Diet vs. Medical Weight Loss: Which Works Best Long-Term?

For decades, we’ve been told that diet and exercise are the only way to stay fit and keep weight off. But today, many experts agree there are scientific reasons why biology can make that goal harder than it sounds. From stress and sleep deprivation to hormonal changes and genetics, modern life stacks the odds against us.

That’s why more providers are reframing weight loss not as a matter of willpower, but as a matter of biology. With medications that mimic natural hormones to curb appetite and rebalance metabolism, the conversation is shifting toward how lifestyle and medicine can work together for lasting results.

- Advertisement -

Featured Experts

• Eduardo Grunvald, MD is an internist and obesity medicine specialist in San Diego
• Amanda Kahn, MD is a board-certified internist in New York

The Body’s Built-In Resistance

Anyone who’s tried to lose weight knows how resistant the body can be. When calories drop, metabolism slows and hunger hormones rise. “The reason many people have trouble losing weight just with lifestyle modification is because the biology gets in the way,” says San Diego obesity specialist Eduardo Grunvald, MD. “The way that our brain responds to our environment, hunger and cravings, especially when you lose weight, is out of your control. It’s determined by genetics, it’s hormonal, it’s neurological.”

That’s why diet alone often isn’t enough. Amanda Kahn, MD, an internist and longevity expert, says today’s environment makes sustainable weight loss especially difficult. “We live in a world where our biology is constantly working against us. Our food is engineered for overconsumption, chronic stress disrupts hormonal balance, sleep deprivation drives insulin resistance and environmental toxins impair mitochondrial function. Medical weight optimization therapies like GLP-1s work by correcting the underlying dysfunctions that make modern weight loss so difficult.”

What Makes GLP-1s Different

GLP-1 medications act on the same hormones that control hunger and blood sugar. “These medications make you less hungry, change cravings, make you have less reward to high-fat, high-sugar foods and make you feel full with less food,” Dr. Grunvald explains. For many patients, that biological reset helps them finally follow through on what they already know to do, eat smaller portions, choose healthier foods and feel satisfied after a meal.

Dr. Kahn adds that these therapies “work with the body’s biology rather than against it. They reset the hormonal signals that control appetite, satiety and insulin function. They reduce inflammation, improve mitochondrial performance and create a new metabolic baseline where the body naturally burns fat and maintains balance.”

More Than a Number on the Scale

Both experts agree the real goal isn’t just hitting a number. “I usually advise staying away from focusing on a target BMI,” says Dr. Grunvald. “That’s just not how we look at it. Percent weight loss, but more importantly, what kind of benefits you’re getting from the weight loss.” Those benefits can include better blood sugar control, improved liver health, reduced joint pain and a stronger cardiovascular profile.

Dr. Kahn says the true reward goes deeper. “Patients not only lose weight but also preserve lean muscle, improve cardiovascular and metabolic health and experience steadier energy and mood. The true outcome is not just weight loss but long-term health optimization and disease prevention.”

Monitoring Progress

Before starting any medical program, testing is key. Dr. Grunvald recommends getting a baseline on blood sugar, kidney function and liver health. Dr. Kahn adds that a full assessment should include fasting glucose, hemoglobin A1C, thyroid and sex hormones, inflammatory markers, and ideally a DEXA or InBody scan to track how fat and muscle shift throughout treatment.

Tracking progress this way helps ensure results are healthy, not just visible. “The goal is not just to lose weight,” says Dr. Kahn, “but to emerge with a stronger, more efficient metabolism and an overall feeling of wellbeing.”

The Takeaway

Long-term success usually takes a combination of lifestyle and science. Diet and exercise will always matter, but biology doesn’t always play fair. That’s where medical treatments can level the field. The future of weight management isn’t just about eating less—it’s about giving the body the right tools to respond the way it should.