Eye Serum or Eye Cream? Here’s How to Choose the Right One for You

Deciding between an eye serum and an eye cream can be confusing. Both contain skin-loving ingredients, but they serve different purposes. Serums typically have a lightweight, liquid texture that delivers targeted treatment, while creams are thicker and more moisturizing. The best choice depends on your skin’s needs: if dark circles are your main concern, go for a serum; if dryness is the issue, a cream will provide the hydration you’re looking for.

When shopping for new products, it’s easy to get wrapped up in pricey formulas, thinking they will deliver the best results. But before you dig deep into your pockets, it’s best to know the facts. “Ingredients backed by clinical research, such as peptides and growth factors for anti-aging, caffeine for puffiness, vitamin C for brightening and hyaluronic acid for hydration, are the most important things to consider,” says Omaha, NE dermatologist Joel Schlessinger, MD.

- Advertisement -

Featured Experts

Eye Serum Vs. Eye Cream

Let’s start with the purpose of each product. According to New York dermatologist Doris Day, MD, eye serums are formulated to deliver active ingredients—like peptides and antioxidants—directly to the skin. Much like a face serum, they provide targeted treatment for specific concerns. Eye creams, on the other hand, function more like traditional moisturizers, hydrating and locking in moisture.

As for texture, Omaha, NE dermatologist Daniel Schlessinger, MD explains that serums have a lighter consistency and a more fluid feel. “They also have smaller molecular structures that allow active ingredients to penetrate deeper into the skin.” Absorption is key for serums, but when it comes to an eye cream, moisture retention is the goal. “For this reason, they are more emollient to protect the delicate skin barrier around the eyes,” says Dr. Schlessinger. Dr. Joel Schlessinger adds that creams are ideal for combating dryness and strengthening the skin around the eyes.

When to Use an Eye Serum or Eye Cream

Using both an eye serum and an eye cream will deliver the best results. Apply the serum first, then layer the cream on top. If you’re choosing just one, it ultimately depends on your skin’s needs. “If you’re dealing with specific concerns like dark circles, puffiness or early signs of aging, a serum will work best to address those issues,” says Dr. Schlessinger. For mature skin or anyone struggling with dryness, a cream provides more nourishment and long-lasting hydration.

When applying either product, use a light touch and remember that a little goes a long way. “Start with a small amount of serum and use your ring finger [because it applies the least amount of pressure] to gently pat around the orbital bone, being careful not to pull or tug,” says Dr. Schlessinger. “Allow it to fully absorb before applying the cream and always apply from the inner corner outward and avoid getting too close to the lash line.”

Eye Serums and Eye Creams to Try

1 / 6

Caffeine is the hero ingredient in this serum, reducing puffiness and brightening dark circles. Plus, the liquid formulation sinks into the skin and absorbs quickly.

2 / 6

This serum has a creamier texture that hydrates and moisturizes the under-eye area. The formula also contains anti-aging ingredients and a potent retinol complex that helps lift and tighten the skin for a more youthful appearance.

3 / 6

If you have sensitive skin, botanical ingredients can be beneficial. “This serum is a natural option that has excellent results,” says Dr. Schlessinger. It features soothing plant extracts, including aloe, calendula and rosemary, to address inflammation and puffiness.

4 / 6

Looking for a cream that addresses several concerns in one swoop? This option from SkinCeuticals is designed to fight a multitude of signs of aging, including crow’s feet, dehydration, dark circles and puffiness. The concentrated formula includes a blend of peptides, including Matrixyl 3000.

5 / 6

This cream combines retinoid esters with vitamin C to target fine lines, wrinkles and discoloration. However, despite containing potent actives, the creamy texture delivers an added layer of hydration, ensuring the delicate area stays well-moisturized.

6 / 6

This eye cream is as rich as it is restorative. It minimizes discoloration and plumps fine lines thanks to its hyaluronic acid and peptide formula. For the best results, use nightly and layer over top of a lightweight eye serum.